Small Dog Toys vs Large Dog Toys: Size Matters

One of the most common mistakes pet parents make is choosing the wrong size toy. A toy perfect for a Golden Retriever could be a choking hazard for a Chihuahua. Getting size right is about safety, not just satisfaction.

Why Toy Size Matters for Safety

If your dog can fit the whole toy past their back teeth, it's too small. Conversely, toys that are too large cause jaw strain and frustration in small dogs.

Small Dog Requirements (Under 20 lbs)

Light enough to carry, small enough to grip, too large to swallow, soft for delicate mouths. Our Coffee Cup Plush Dog Toy has appropriate dimensions for small dogs with GentlePlush fabric soft enough for delicate mouthers.

Large Dog Requirements (Over 50 lbs)

Large enough to prevent swallowing, durable for powerful jaws, substantial enough to satisfy. Products like our Steak toy and Barkin Bag offer the size and durability larger breeds need.

Puppies and Multi-Dog Households

For puppies, buy sized for expected adult size. For multi-dog households with size differences, keep separate toy boxes and supervise mixed play. Our SuperSqueak technology in the Avocado toy adapts across sizes with adjustable volume.

When in doubt, size up — a slightly larger toy is never a choking hazard. For multi-toy value, check our 420 Chill Pack Bundle at pawty.com.